Sundance to Ryan: Arrogant Finalist Claiming Victory

16. it is a shame...i was SHOCKED to say the least that Sabrina got booted instead of Hilary (is that her name?) and Sundance instead of Sanajay. Good LORD i was not expecting those two to stay!

I hope it's not Blake that he's talking about. That kid rocks it...he's fun. I like someone getting in there and mixing it up a bit. I doubt he's going to win...but he sure is fun to watch. meow.
I think that Melinda should get it

Posted at 12:34PM on Mar 9th 2007 by Iowa Girl

17. I was a little surprised by Sundance getting voted off as well.

That Sanjaya kid is a joke...I would think that maybe there were a bunch of little girls voting for him cut they think he's cute (girly lookin' sissy) but my 12 year old daughter thinks he is EWWWWW. Girly hair, not a great voice and he hula's..woohoo. :0)

Posted at 12:42PM on Mar 9th 2007 by Kathy

18. The two worst guys are the guy that always wears a hat and the Menudo looking kid. They can't sing and they are hard to look at! This Sundance guy wasn't bad. The pretty boy that they kicked off was actually one of the better singers. I hate AI. I think they are hypnotizing us into watching this crap!

Posted at 12:49PM on Mar 9th 2007 by Just an opinion

19. Sundance should have stayed instead of that ugly--untidy looking Sanjaya---who, himself, looked surprised he will be part of the "magic" 12. At least Sundance is so pleasing to hear when he belts, unlike Sanjaya who seems to only mumble which makes him look so weird having the guts to do the hula!!! Get out Sanjaya and do us a big favor!

Posted at 12:44PM on Mar 9th 2007 by Lita

20. I always felt that the whole voting thing is done wrong! It should be change so only one vote per person can call. I hope Sundance will be offered a contract to sing in Vegas...He is good!

Posted at 3:29PM on Mar 9th 2007 by Togo

21. tis sad to see pube chin go! i think it's because he chose Jeremy and the target audience of the show is too young to know what the hell the song is....in other news, who can believe the judges didn't know the 311 song, that's ridiculous

Posted at 12:41PM on Mar 9th 2007 by Me

22. ca girl, are you retarded or has the california sun just melted the half of your brain that worked. competition, not popularity contest, he has every right to be bitter, being left off the top 12 means he won't be on the american idol cd, being left out of the top 10 means he won't be part of the tour, both of those things generate money. i'm sure he wasn't really thinking he would win, but those other two scenarios would have given him some money. now the "competition" is left with a couple of turds mixed in with the main course

Posted at 1:17PM on Mar 9th 2007 by wasabi joe

23. Sanjaya?? You gotta be kidding! I wonder what 37 million people were listening too! He can't sing, he's lacking any charisma and boring as hell to watch!! You go Sundance. You have great talent, go out there an show American Idol what you can do!! So sorry to hear of your family's loss. Go girls, the guys that are left all suck!

Posted at 12:41PM on Mar 9th 2007 by lynn

24. I know, It is Blake!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Posted at 12:47PM on Mar 9th 2007 by AJ

25. WTF!!!!! Are you kidding me!!! How did that indian kid get to stay.....I mean c'mon!!!..I'll stop watching cause I was voting for Sundance...he was in another league ....It'll be a female who wins this...hopin' for Lakisha.

Posted at 12:55PM on Mar 9th 2007 by benji

26. I cannot believe he was voted off.. America really does have bad taste to keep that indian kid in there. He has a ton of maturing to do... Sundance would have had that competition won!! I hope someone gets him in on a record deal! I'll be the first in line to buy it.

Posted at 1:00PM on Mar 9th 2007 by Jennifer

27. GRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRR! I am soooo mad that Sundance was voted off last night! That's just insane! Sanjaya is horrid! I know who that "SOB" is...it's that Phil Stacey character! You can tell by his attitude. I hate to burst his bubble...but it's going to be either LaKisha or Melinda that take this one home! NO ONE at this point should be so arrogant!

Sundance...we here in Houston still love you! You and your family are in my prayers. I heard the news about the cousin on Fox News last night and my heart hurts for their family!

Posted at 12:56PM on Mar 9th 2007 by Amy

28. The whole premise of American Idol is that the American public chooses the winner. I thought Paula was extremely rude to that young man Sanjaya...America voted and we chose him. Simon of course is just an ass to make the rude comments on their looks and then say..it's a singing competition. ( He really needs to make up his mind...immature bully tactic fashion critique or singing competition). I felt bad for Haley and Sanjaya after the judges immature behavior. If they don't like whom America chooses..they need to change the rules...otherwise..suck it up and get over it. America has voted and we chose Haley and Sanjaya. Different strokes for different folks..I like them both and I'm happy they made it through.

09 March 2007 17:41

Posted at 1:46PM on Mar 17th 2007 by PFS

29. It's Haley (not Hilary) that should've gone, NOT Sabrina. Amercia must have been drinking too much vodka too! Sundance should be there! WHEN will they get rid of Jungle Book Boy??? I can't stand to even look at him!!!

Posted at 12:57PM on Mar 9th 2007 by LAWoman

30. I agree with #22 and have been saying this for ages............1 VOTE PER PERSON!!! I think it's on Dancing with the Stars where you can vote 10 times which is alright because there might be more than 1 person in a family and they each have a different choice. But this voting over and over just isn't fair. I was totally shocked that Sundance got voted off and that girly Sanjaya is still on. Every Indian must be voting for him. He is so dull and has no talent. The guy with the curly hair needs to do something with that mess. The guy can sing but he sure isn't what I would want to see as an American Idol. Glad the girl with the pictures on the Internet also got voted off......... FINALLY!!!!

Posted at 2:38PM on Mar 9th 2007 by I agree